Corn Syrup Replacements
By KerryAnnOne of the biggest problems with holiday foods is avoiding the high fructose corn syrup in products and the corn syrup in your Christmas baking. Even when you decide to make compromise foods, many of them call for corn syrup. That cuts whole classes of recipes out.
After talking with some online friends, I found that some use agave successfully for replacing corn syrup in some dishes, but I couldn’t find where anyone said it had worked well on candies. So I started googling and I found several recipes online to make a corn syrup replacement. This recipe worked the best for us, and is now my go-to so I can make pecan pie and caramels and nougats for Christmas parties.
From the Christmas Menu Mailer
1 cup sugar
¾ cup water
¼ tsp cream of tartar
Pinch salt
Combine everything in a saucepan and bring to a boil. Reduce to a simmer and cover. Cook for 3 minutes (this washes down any remaining sugar crystals on the sides of the pan back into the solution so it won’t crystalize later). Uncover and cook to softball stage. Pour into a clean, hot mason jar and cool completely. Will store for a long time in the fridge.
Related Posts
- Twelve Days of Christmas: Whipped Coconut Milk
- Twelve Days of Christmas: Decorative Soap Balls
- Twelve Days of Christmas: Citrus Salt and Sugar Scrub
- Twelve Days of Christmas: Shiny Stars
- Twelve Days of Christmas: Grain-Free Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies
- Twelve Days of Christmas: Sugar Cookies
- Twelve Days of Christmas: Thick, Rich Chocolate Peppermint Custard
- Get Real: Kids and The Holiday Sugar Rush
- Real Food Storage: Peppermint Patties
- Sugar and Immunity: How Many Carbs Make Me Prone to Illness? Popcorn Balls
- Does Sugar Affect Immunity? Swiss Apple Pie
Disclaimer: Some of the links in some of my posts are affiliate links. When you click them you allow me to cover a small portion of the cost of this blog. Blogging isn’t cheap and I appreciate your support so we can keep churning out awesome recipes. Using my affiliate link is like leaving a tip. Thank you. You can read more of our disclaimers here.
KerryAnn Foster runs Cooking Traditional Foods, the longest running Traditional Foods Menu Mailer on the internet, now in its seventh volume. KerryAnn has eleven years of traditional foods experience and is a former Weston A. Price Foundation chapter leader. Read about KerryAnn’s journey to health through multiple miscarriages, celiac disease, food allergies and intolerances, obesity, adrenal fatigue and heavy metals.
Founded in 2005, CTF helps you feed your family nourishing foods they will love. With two choices of Menu Mailers, multiple eBooks, Print Books and video-based classes, KerryAnn makes traditional foods easy, accessible, affordable and family friendly for everyone.
KerryAnn founded Nourished Living Network, a network for traditional food and natural living bloggers, in 2011. NLN provides support, publicity and networking opportunities for bloggers all across the traditional foods spectrum. Our Recipe Gallery features recipes from the fifty member blogs and growing.





















Thanks so much for sharing this recipe! I looked and looked for something similar when I came across an awesome sounding recipe for pumpkin fudge. However, all my searching brought up nothing. Not even close. I had completely given up on the recipe. I was also very interested to read about the reason for covering the saucepan for 3 minutes. I blogged about a fudge recipe once that had similar instructions and never knew why that was in the directions. (Even more mysterious, because the recipe for fudge only called for having the lid on for 1 minute) So thanks for that tidbit!
~Karen
Karen recently posted..Sweet Success (Sydney’s)
What type of sugar would you use for this?
Sucanot? Coconut? or what ?
Personally, I use white sugar for this since it’s a once-a-year treat, but I know others have used rapadura or sucanat successfully.